Ag Producers Less Optimistic Amid Trade Concerns

Collette Schultz

Farmers worried about losing ag exports

The 5-point decline in sentiment comes as a result of producers’ less-optimistic perceptions of both current conditions and future expectations.

The Index of Current Conditions fell 9 points in March to 134, while the Index of Future Expectations dropped by 4 points to 135.

The barometer and both sub-indices are based on a monthly survey of 400 U.S. agricultural producers.

Trade war

On the March survey, producers expressed both concern and uncertainty surrounding trade.

Nearly half (47 percent) of respondents said that a trade war negatively impacting agricultural exports was somewhat likely, compared with just 28 percent who thought it was unlikely.

Producers also were asked about the likelihood of a U.S. withdrawal from the North American Free Trade Agreement (NAFTA). More than one-third expressed uncertainty, while 28 percent expected the U.S. to remain in NAFTA and 34 percent said they expect the U.S. to exit the agreement.

“Interestingly, when comparing results from the two trade questions, a larger share of respondents reported a significant decline in agricultural exports from a trade war was more likely than the U.S. withdrawing from NAFTA,” said James Mintert, director of Purdue University’s Center for Commercial Agriculture and principal investigator on the barometer project.

Mintert said these results are important for two reasons.

“First, nearly half of producers rated the risk of a trade war as at least somewhat likely. Second, producers’ concerns about risks to agricultural trade are broader than just the ongoing NAFTA situation.”

Holding onto money

The March survey also asked producers whether they thought now was a good time to make large farm investments, such as machinery or buildings. At 68 percent, the portion of producers indicating now is a bad time to make large investments is the highest level observed since May 2017.

Mintert said this could be related to the trade situation.

“Concerns about agricultural exports, especially as they relate to Chinese tariffs on U.S. ag products, could be one reason why fewer producers said now is a good time to make large farm investments,” he said.